THE THESIS INVESTIGATES, FROM A COMPARATIVE PRIVATE LAW PERSPECTIVE, THE LEGAL CONTINUITY OF ART COLLECTIONS WHEN OWNERSHIP OF THE ARTWORKS, POWERS OF ADMINISTRATION, INTERESTS, PURPOSES, VALUE, AND CONTROL CEASE TO BE CONCENTRATED IN THE SAME PERSON. THE RESEARCH STARTS FROM THE PREMISE THAT, ALTHOUGH A COLLECTION MAY BE IDENTIFIABLE AS A CORPUS BY VIRTUE OF PROVENANCE, DOCUMENTATION, THE SEQUENCE OF ACQUISITIONS, AND THE RELATIONSHIPS AMONG THE WORKS, IT NEED NOT THEREFORE BE TREATED AS AN AUTONOMOUS UNITARY ASSET: INDIVIDUAL WORKS REMAIN, AS A RULE, SEPARATELY OWNABLE AND TRANSFERABLE. AGAINST THIS BACKGROUND, THE THESIS EXAMINES THE RULES THROUGH WHICH TRUSTS, FOUNDATIONS, AND COMPANIES ORGANISE THESE RELATIONSHIPS OVER TIME AND THE EFFECTS THEY PRODUCE WHEN THE ARRANGEMENTS ESTABLISHED ENCOUNTER COMPETING CLAIMS ARISING FROM CREDITORS, FAMILY AND SUCCESSION LAW, OR PARTICIPATION RIGHTS. THE COMPARISON IS CONDUCTED BY REFERENCE TO FUNCTIONS AND LEGAL FORMANTS, SELECTING JURISDICTIONS ACCORDING TO THE SPECIFIC RULE UNDER EXAMINATION AND PRESERVING THE DISTINCT AUTHORITY OF LEGISLATION, CASE LAW, RESTATEMENTS, UNIFORM AND MODEL LAWS, REGULATORY FRAMEWORKS, AND PROFESSIONAL PRACTICES. IN RELATION TO THE TRUST, THE ANALYSIS RECONSTRUCTS THE DISSOCIATION BETWEEN THE FUND, FIDUCIARY POWER, AND PROTECTED INTEREST, DISTINGUISHING THE EXTERNAL EFFECTIVENESS OF TRANSACTIONS, THE CONFORMITY OF THE EXERCISE OF POWER, AND THE AVAILABLE REMEDIES. IN RELATION TO THE FOUNDATION, IT EXAMINES THE INSTITUTIONAL ATTRIBUTION OF THE PURPOSE, GOVERNANCE WITHOUT MEMBERS, THE LEGAL QUALIFICATION OF THE FOUNDATION’S ASSETS, AND THE CONDITIONS UNDER WHICH ITS PROGRAMME MAY BE ADAPTED. IN RELATION TO THE COMPANY, IT SEPARATES THE ATTRIBUTION OF THE ARTWORKS TO THE CORPORATE ESTATE FROM THE PARTICIPATION INTEREST, SHOWING HOW VALUE AND CONTROL MAY CIRCULATE WITHOUT ANY TRANSFER OF THE CORPORATE ASSETS THEMSELVES. MATTER OF ROTHKO, THE BARNES FOUNDATION LITIGATION, AND THE POLAROID CASE TEST THESE FINDINGS, RESPECTIVELY, IN THE CONTEXT OF FIDUCIARY MISCONDUCT, THE CONTROLLED MODIFICATION OF A DESIGNATED PURPOSE, AND THE INSOLVENCY OF THE ENTITY TO WHICH THE COLLECTION IS ATTRIBUTED. THE THESIS DEMONSTRATES THAT THE CONTINUITY OF AN ART COLLECTION IS NEITHER A UNITARY LEGAL EFFECT NOR AN ABSTRACT DEGREE OF PROTECTION. CONTINUITY OF ATTRIBUTION, PRESERVATION OF THE ARTISTIC AND DOCUMENTARY CORPUS, CONTINUITY OF VALUE, DURABILITY OF PURPOSE, AND STABILITY OR MOBILITY OF POWER ARE GOVERNED BY DISTINCT RULES AND MAY COMBINE IN DIFFERENT WAYS. ASSET SEPARATION LIKEWISE ACQUIRES MEANING ONLY IN RELATION TO THE PARTICULAR CLAIM ASSERTED AND TO THE ESTATE THAT SERVES AS SECURITY FOR IT. THE TERTIUM COMPARATIONIS IS THEREFORE IDENTIFIED NOT IN THE LEGAL INSTITUTION EMPLOYED AS A WHOLE, BUT IN THE SPECIFIC LEGAL RELATIONSHIP THAT IS, IN EACH INSTANCE, STABILISED OR TRANSFORMED. THE CONTINUITY OF THE COLLECTION THUS EMERGES AS THE RESULT OF THE LEGAL REGULATION OF THE RELATIONSHIPS AMONG ARTWORKS, ASSETS, VALUE, PURPOSE, AND THE PERSONS VESTED WITH THE RELEVANT POWERS, WITHOUT REQUIRING THE CONSTRUCTION OF AN AUTONOMOUS LEGAL REGIME FOR THE COLLECTION ITSELF.
LA TESI INDAGA, IN PROSPETTIVA COMPARATA E NELL’AMBITO DEL DIRITTO PRIVATO, LA CONTINUITÀ GIURIDICA DELLA COLLEZIONE D’ARTE QUANDO APPARTENENZA DELLE OPERE, POTERE DI AMMINISTRAZIONE, INTERESSE, DESTINAZIONE, VALORE E CONTROLLO CESSANO DI CONCENTRARSI NEL MEDESIMO SOGGETTO. LA RICERCA MUOVE DALLA CONSTATAZIONE CHE LA RACCOLTA, PUR RICONOSCIBILE COME CORPUS PER PROVENIENZA, DOCUMENTAZIONE, SUCCESSIONE DEGLI ACQUISTI E RELAZIONI TRA LE OPERE, NON DEVE PER CIÒ ESSERE ASSUNTA COME AUTONOMO BENE UNITARIO: LE SINGOLE RES RESTANO, DI REGOLA, SEPARATAMENTE TITOLABILI E CIRCOLABILI. SU QUESTA PREMESSA VIENE VERIFICATO ATTRAVERSO QUALI REGOLE TRUST, FONDAZIONE E SOCIETÀ ORGANIZZINO NEL TEMPO TALI RELAZIONI E QUALI EFFETTI PRODUCANO QUANDO L’ASSETTO PREDISPOSTO INCONTRA PRETESE CREDITORIE, FAMILIARI, SUCCESSORIE O PARTECIPATIVE. IL CONFRONTO È CONDOTTO PER FUNZIONI E FORMANTI, SELEZIONANDO GLI ORDINAMENTI IN RELAZIONE ALLA SPECIFICA REGOLA ESAMINATA E MANTENENDO DISTINTA L’AUTORITÀ DI LEGISLAZIONE, GIURISPRUDENZA, RESTATEMENTS, UNIFORM E MODEL LAWS, DISCIPLINE REGOLATORIE E PRASSI PROFESSIONALI. NEL TRUST L’ANALISI RICOSTRUISCE LA DISSOCIAZIONE TRA FONDO, POTERE FIDUCIARIO E INTERESSE, DISTINGUENDO EFFICACIA ESTERNA DELL’ATTO, CONFORMITÀ DELL’ESERCIZIO E RIMEDI; NELLA FONDAZIONE ESAMINA L’ENTIFICAZIONE DELLA DESTINAZIONE, IL GOVERNO SENZA SOCI, LA QUALIFICAZIONE DEL PATRIMONIO E LE CONDIZIONI DI ADATTAMENTO DEL PROGRAMMA; NELLA SOCIETÀ SEPARA L’IMPUTAZIONE DELLE OPERE DALLA PARTECIPAZIONE, MOSTRANDO COME VALORE E CONTROLLO POSSANO CIRCOLARE SENZA TRASFERIMENTO DEI BENI SOCIALI. MATTER OF ROTHKO, LA VICENDA BARNES E IL CASO POLAROID VERIFICANO TALI ACQUISIZIONI, RISPETTIVAMENTE, NELLA PATOLOGIA DEL POTERE FIDUCIARIO, NELLA MODIFICAZIONE CONTROLLATA DELLA DESTINAZIONE E NELLA CRISI DEL CENTRO DI IMPUTAZIONE. L’INDAGINE DIMOSTRA CHE LA CONTINUITÀ DELLA COLLEZIONE NON COSTITUISCE UN EFFETTO UNITARIO NÉ UN GRADO ASTRATTO DI PROTEZIONE. PERMANENZA DELL’IMPUTAZIONE, CONSERVAZIONE DEL CORPUS ARTISTICO-DOCUMENTALE, CONTINUITÀ DEL VALORE, DURATA DELLA DESTINAZIONE E STABILITÀ O MOBILITÀ DEL POTERE SEGUONO REGOLE DISTINTE E POSSONO COMBINARSI DIVERSAMENTE. ANCHE LA SEPARAZIONE PATRIMONIALE ASSUME SIGNIFICATO SOLTANTO RISPETTO ALLA PRETESA CONSIDERATA E AL PATRIMONIO CHE NE COSTITUISCE LA GARANZIA. IL TERTIUM COMPARATIONIS È PERTANTO INDIVIDUATO NON NELL’ISTITUTO NOMINALMENTE IMPIEGATO, MA NELLA RELAZIONE GIURIDICA DI VOLTA IN VOLTA STABILIZZATA O TRASFORMATA. LA CONTINUITÀ DELLA COLLEZIONE EMERGE COSÌ COME RISULTATO DELLA DISCIPLINA DEI RAPPORTI TRA OPERE, PATRIMONIO, VALORE, DESTINAZIONE E SOGGETTI TITOLARI DEI RELATIVI POTERI, SENZA RICHIEDERE LA COSTRUZIONE DI UN AUTONOMO REGIME GIURIDICO DELLA RACCOLTA.
LA COLLEZIONE D’ARTE TRA APPARTENENZA E CONTINUITÀ. GOVERNO, SEPARAZIONE E CIRCOLAZIONE NEL DIRITTO PRIVATO COMPARATO / Vera Iuzzolino , 2026 Oct 28. 38. ciclo, Anno Accademico 2024/25.
LA COLLEZIONE D’ARTE TRA APPARTENENZA E CONTINUITÀ. GOVERNO, SEPARAZIONE E CIRCOLAZIONE NEL DIRITTO PRIVATO COMPARATO
IUZZOLINO, VERA
2026
Abstract
THE THESIS INVESTIGATES, FROM A COMPARATIVE PRIVATE LAW PERSPECTIVE, THE LEGAL CONTINUITY OF ART COLLECTIONS WHEN OWNERSHIP OF THE ARTWORKS, POWERS OF ADMINISTRATION, INTERESTS, PURPOSES, VALUE, AND CONTROL CEASE TO BE CONCENTRATED IN THE SAME PERSON. THE RESEARCH STARTS FROM THE PREMISE THAT, ALTHOUGH A COLLECTION MAY BE IDENTIFIABLE AS A CORPUS BY VIRTUE OF PROVENANCE, DOCUMENTATION, THE SEQUENCE OF ACQUISITIONS, AND THE RELATIONSHIPS AMONG THE WORKS, IT NEED NOT THEREFORE BE TREATED AS AN AUTONOMOUS UNITARY ASSET: INDIVIDUAL WORKS REMAIN, AS A RULE, SEPARATELY OWNABLE AND TRANSFERABLE. AGAINST THIS BACKGROUND, THE THESIS EXAMINES THE RULES THROUGH WHICH TRUSTS, FOUNDATIONS, AND COMPANIES ORGANISE THESE RELATIONSHIPS OVER TIME AND THE EFFECTS THEY PRODUCE WHEN THE ARRANGEMENTS ESTABLISHED ENCOUNTER COMPETING CLAIMS ARISING FROM CREDITORS, FAMILY AND SUCCESSION LAW, OR PARTICIPATION RIGHTS. THE COMPARISON IS CONDUCTED BY REFERENCE TO FUNCTIONS AND LEGAL FORMANTS, SELECTING JURISDICTIONS ACCORDING TO THE SPECIFIC RULE UNDER EXAMINATION AND PRESERVING THE DISTINCT AUTHORITY OF LEGISLATION, CASE LAW, RESTATEMENTS, UNIFORM AND MODEL LAWS, REGULATORY FRAMEWORKS, AND PROFESSIONAL PRACTICES. IN RELATION TO THE TRUST, THE ANALYSIS RECONSTRUCTS THE DISSOCIATION BETWEEN THE FUND, FIDUCIARY POWER, AND PROTECTED INTEREST, DISTINGUISHING THE EXTERNAL EFFECTIVENESS OF TRANSACTIONS, THE CONFORMITY OF THE EXERCISE OF POWER, AND THE AVAILABLE REMEDIES. IN RELATION TO THE FOUNDATION, IT EXAMINES THE INSTITUTIONAL ATTRIBUTION OF THE PURPOSE, GOVERNANCE WITHOUT MEMBERS, THE LEGAL QUALIFICATION OF THE FOUNDATION’S ASSETS, AND THE CONDITIONS UNDER WHICH ITS PROGRAMME MAY BE ADAPTED. IN RELATION TO THE COMPANY, IT SEPARATES THE ATTRIBUTION OF THE ARTWORKS TO THE CORPORATE ESTATE FROM THE PARTICIPATION INTEREST, SHOWING HOW VALUE AND CONTROL MAY CIRCULATE WITHOUT ANY TRANSFER OF THE CORPORATE ASSETS THEMSELVES. MATTER OF ROTHKO, THE BARNES FOUNDATION LITIGATION, AND THE POLAROID CASE TEST THESE FINDINGS, RESPECTIVELY, IN THE CONTEXT OF FIDUCIARY MISCONDUCT, THE CONTROLLED MODIFICATION OF A DESIGNATED PURPOSE, AND THE INSOLVENCY OF THE ENTITY TO WHICH THE COLLECTION IS ATTRIBUTED. THE THESIS DEMONSTRATES THAT THE CONTINUITY OF AN ART COLLECTION IS NEITHER A UNITARY LEGAL EFFECT NOR AN ABSTRACT DEGREE OF PROTECTION. CONTINUITY OF ATTRIBUTION, PRESERVATION OF THE ARTISTIC AND DOCUMENTARY CORPUS, CONTINUITY OF VALUE, DURABILITY OF PURPOSE, AND STABILITY OR MOBILITY OF POWER ARE GOVERNED BY DISTINCT RULES AND MAY COMBINE IN DIFFERENT WAYS. ASSET SEPARATION LIKEWISE ACQUIRES MEANING ONLY IN RELATION TO THE PARTICULAR CLAIM ASSERTED AND TO THE ESTATE THAT SERVES AS SECURITY FOR IT. THE TERTIUM COMPARATIONIS IS THEREFORE IDENTIFIED NOT IN THE LEGAL INSTITUTION EMPLOYED AS A WHOLE, BUT IN THE SPECIFIC LEGAL RELATIONSHIP THAT IS, IN EACH INSTANCE, STABILISED OR TRANSFORMED. THE CONTINUITY OF THE COLLECTION THUS EMERGES AS THE RESULT OF THE LEGAL REGULATION OF THE RELATIONSHIPS AMONG ARTWORKS, ASSETS, VALUE, PURPOSE, AND THE PERSONS VESTED WITH THE RELEVANT POWERS, WITHOUT REQUIRING THE CONSTRUCTION OF AN AUTONOMOUS LEGAL REGIME FOR THE COLLECTION ITSELF.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Abstract Tesi.pdf
embargo fino al 28/10/2027
Descrizione: Abstract
Tipologia:
Tesi di dottorato
Dimensione
73.68 kB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
73.68 kB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri Richiedi una copia |
|
Tesi di Dottorato - La collezione d'arte tra appartenenza e continuita?.pdf
embargo fino al 28/10/2027
Descrizione: LA COLLEZIONE D’ARTE TRA APPARTENENZA E CONTINUITÀ. GOVERNO, SEPARAZIONE E CIRCOLAZIONE NEL DIRITTO PRIVATO COMPARATO
Tipologia:
Tesi di dottorato
Dimensione
2.54 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
2.54 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri Richiedi una copia |
I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.


