Online disinformation is a complex phenomenon requiring social and technical models capable of integrating community participation with statistical robustness. This paper examines the "Community Notes" (CN) approach adopted by X (formerly Twitter), analyzing its transition from centralized moderation to a decentralized, consensus-driven system. Beyond the sociological principle of the "Wisdom of the Crowd," we propose that Community Notes functions as a distributed Bayesian inference engine. By utilizing a "bridging" algorithm that requires agreement across dissimilar user groups, the system effectively manipulates the Likelihood function P (R|V ) to filter out partisan noise, thereby updating the Posterior probability of content reliability. This mechanism operationalizes a shift from objective realism to a constructed, relational truth, effectively mitigating cognitive biases. The study further reviews the system’s efficacy in reducing the viral spread of misleading content, its limitations regarding speed and scale, and the transparency offered by its public datasets, which render the system scientifically replicable and auditable.
Effective Methodologies for Identifying and Reporting Misleading Online Content: The Decentralized Community Notes Approach
luigi catuogno;clemente galdi;fiammetta marulli;gennaro ragucci
In corso di stampa
Abstract
Online disinformation is a complex phenomenon requiring social and technical models capable of integrating community participation with statistical robustness. This paper examines the "Community Notes" (CN) approach adopted by X (formerly Twitter), analyzing its transition from centralized moderation to a decentralized, consensus-driven system. Beyond the sociological principle of the "Wisdom of the Crowd," we propose that Community Notes functions as a distributed Bayesian inference engine. By utilizing a "bridging" algorithm that requires agreement across dissimilar user groups, the system effectively manipulates the Likelihood function P (R|V ) to filter out partisan noise, thereby updating the Posterior probability of content reliability. This mechanism operationalizes a shift from objective realism to a constructed, relational truth, effectively mitigating cognitive biases. The study further reviews the system’s efficacy in reducing the viral spread of misleading content, its limitations regarding speed and scale, and the transparency offered by its public datasets, which render the system scientifically replicable and auditable.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.


